For years, this blog and many others gained lots of views by constantly harping on brachycephalic breeds, especially bulldogs and pugs. Those were in the days when I was a bit more edgelord in technique, and those were the days when I was significantly more sanctimonious and humorless as person, too.
Sometimes, the ol’ ‘possum spends all his time climbing the persimmon tree, only to discovery the tree is a hickory. And then he has to climb down and figure out where the persimmon tree actually is.
This is where I am as a person, as a blogger/writer, and as a dog enthusiast. The persimmon tree is somewhere else, and that means taking stock of where I once was and how I can do better.
The issues with brachycephalic breeds are that they never fully oxygenate themselves, and they often have a hard time cooling themselves. I know of certain blogs that spend post after post looking a bulldog and pug nostrils with lots of shaming involved.
The problem is that pet people most don’t care what sanctimonious internet personalities think, and the dog show people, especially those at the top of the game, don’t care either. The show dog people are going to spend money on health testing and c-sections on their bulldogs, and they will sell them at a high price to homes with resources to care for them.
As pets, they can live full and wonderful lives. They don’t have to have the endurance of a Dalmatian or German short-haired pointer.
Further, all this shaming didn’t work at all. The popularity of these dogs continues to be quite high. And this shaming has given fuel to the anti-breeder sentiment in the country, which revels in creating division among dog people. This division is why we are getting so many weird laws passed in state houses, ones that ultimately harm responsible dog breeders and do nothing to improve animal welfare.
So I’ve come to the conclusion that what I’ve written about bulldogs and the like in previous years, though well-meaning, has ultimately been harmful to the things I love the most.
Even if the welfare issues associated with brachycephalic dogs were the greatest issue facing dogs today, shaming people won’t solve the problem. People will dig in and tell you how awful you are, and whatever wisdom you might have will be simply ignored.
And when we look at the actual welfare issues facing these breeds are they really suffering all that much? If they live in homes where they are pampered and well-cared for, they are doing pretty well, better than perhaps a billion people living on this planet.
I support educating and disclosing what potential risks of owning a bulldog or pug might entail. I guarantee you that the ethical breeders producing these dogs are disclosing these risks to puppy buyers.
And that should be all that is required of breeder of any breed or strain.
If bulldogs, French bulldogs, and pugs really do have this level of welfare concern, then it will become obvious. In ten years, the craze will have swept through the pet market, and people will be buying something other fad breed.
But I suspect that these health and welfare problems are much easier to mitigate than we have been led to believe, and if they are, why did I waste so much time with this nonsense?
It didn’t even work. And I was a total jerk.